The Performer and the Audience: The Last Waltz and Stop Making Sense

The concert film is the intersection between a recording of a live show and a documentary. It's a cinematic representation of a live event; it attempts to recreate for the theater audience the experience of the audience at that live event, or, in the case, create a transcendent experience that is wholly unique. In the popular conscience, the two greatest concert films of all time are generally considered to be Stop Making Sense (Jonathan Demme, 1984) and The Last Waltz (Martin Scorsese, 1978). Stop Making Sense presents three performances by Talking Heads (the foundational New Wave band founded by RISD-alumni David Byrne and Chris Frantz) specifically for the film as a recreation of their live performances for the tour supporting the album Speaking in Tongues. The Last Waltz was presented as the final performance of The Band, the iconic American group that began doing backup for artists like Bob Dylan. Although both are masterpieces, they offer fundamentally different approaches to the concert film.

The Last Waltz film is more than just a recording of The Last Waltz performance. Scorsese includes several largely scripted (or at least obviously pre-structured) interviews with The Band member, and friend of Martin Scorsese, Robbie Robertson. It also includes some performances that are performed on sound stage in what constitutes more of a proto music video than that of a live performance. The film is better positioned as a documentary about The Band than strictly a concert film, giving the film audience access to more information and lines of sight than any live audience member would have access to. Stop Making Sense presents a much more streamlined experience. Film follows the concert through with no frills our added details; the viewer is only allowed to experience what is on the stage and rarely even the live audience at the actual show.

It seems like the films want to bring their respective audiences wholly different experiences. The Last Waltz intends to re-create the experience of an audience member. They learn about the band, they hear their favorite songs and they celebrate the special appearances of legendary artists like Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, and Bob Dylan. Stop Making Sense means to re-create the experience of the performer; minute glances are shown between lead-singer David Byrne and bassist Tina Weymouth, the facial expressions. The lack of live audience being seen in the film displays how hyper focused Demme’s camera is upon the happenings on the actual stage. The joys of The Last Waltz are the joys of seeing a great live show while the joys of Stop Making Sense of the joys of performing a great show.

Previous
Previous

Reality TV as Propaganda: The Girls Next Door, Gender, and the American Invasion of Iraq

Next
Next

Barry Lyndon 50 Years Later: Bring Back Boring Movies