Barry Lyndon (Stanley Kubrick, 1975) is, on its surface, an objectively boring movie. Its three-hour runtime meanders through plot, lingers obsessively on intricate details, and hardly offers any gratification of expectations the audience might have. The titled protagonist’s friends die fast, his lovers are lost even faster, and as he ascends into the company of progressively less sympathetic aristocrats, any semblance of wish fulfillment vanishes. In addition to the film’s complete disregard for viewer satisfaction, its conceptual mundanity is undeniable. Yet, this apparent mundanity is integral to Barry Lyndon’s status as an enduring masterpiece.
The film is broken up into two parts, the first documenting the story of Barry’s (Ryan O’Neal) war-consumed adolescence turned meteoric rise into English high society, and the second exploring the details of his fall from power into ruin. In short, Barry goes to war, escapes, marries someone rich, and loses his money. Every minute of this seemingly simple structure, however, is imbued with fascinating emotional and intellectual depth that creates a filmic experience unlike any other.
Stanley Kubrick is a master at creating a sense of scale. In Eyes Wide Shut (1999), the terrifying concept of an underground cult network is established in practically one single scene. Through Kubrick’s visionary work in The Shining (1980), Jack Nicholson is transformed into an unstoppable force of murder. But cults and serial killers are much easier to aggrandize than a normal guy living his life in the 1700s. Centering a grandiose period piece around a guy who is anything but grand is a perplexing choice. But equally confounding is the fact that Barry’s normality is one of the most successful aspects of the film. It is impossible to form a singular cohesive opinion on the Irish rogue when sympathy, pity, anger, and surprise surround his every move in the film. It is puzzling how a character can make so many wrong and right choices, embody the heart of a story that feels larger than life, and yet lack a fundamental significance as a character. Barry is forced into riveting situations, and the inescapable isolation he constantly experiences is interesting, but his insubstantiality remains constant. It is this value placed in an unremarkable character that speaks to the immense beauty and power Kubrick finds in unexpected places. Witnessing a character so devoid of self-identity exhibit such control over the people around him and the narrative itself evokes a compelling relatability, entirely transforming the connotation of boredom many viewers might see in themselves.
Fifty years later, this boringness has only grown in originality. In a time where so many movies today seem wholly invested in cheap gratification, simple tricks, and packing as much plot into as little time as possible, a slow-paced film is a breath of fresh air. Being able to ruminate on infinitely layered character relationships and developments, to visually absorb each moment in its painterly magnificence, and be immersed in the meticulously crafted period-accurate costumes and sets is a privilege many modern movies are not afforded. In all its boringness, Barry Lyndon somehow manages to exceed the capacity of cinematic storytelling.
For one, every single frame seems plucked directly from a Watteau, Gainsborough, or Hogarth painting. Kubrick’s famously breathtaking lighting design is at its height of perfection in Barry Lyndon. Even its narration, with a pompously formal and charmingly dry performance from Michael Horden, saturates every scene with a storybook quality.
The film’s historical accuracy, however, would categorize this film more as a textbook of sorts. On-location filming and meticulous details of high society and militaristic operations produce palpable authenticity. The costumes are accurate down to the very fabric used, with designs for all of the clothing being derived directly from sketches of the period, while still communicating so much of Barry’s effort to fit into the world around him.
In addition to each of these pillars upon which Barry Lyndon rests its excellency, it is a genuinely funny movie. Kubrick commits to comedic beats and motifs throughout the entire film. Death, class inequality, xenophobia, fortune, and misfortune are all portrayed with gravity and truth. Yet, all of them are joked about in ways that ensure the film does not take itself too seriously. It’s this levity that enhances the darkness of Barry Lyndon and prevents the film from losing itself in its details.
Guided by an emotionally astonishing core, enhanced by its technical aspects, and gilded with boldly boring choices, Kubrick’s masterpiece echoes through time as a reminder that boring movies will always maintain importance in cinema’s past, present, and future.