Premiering in 2005, “The Girls Next Door” was a reality TV series that followed Hugh Hefner’s three girlfriends, Holly Madison, Bridget Marquardt, and Kendra Wilkinson, as they navigated life in the Playboy Mansion. Most of the show revolved around the three women traveling, planning parties, and helping sustain the Playboy brand. Hugh Hefner existed in the background of the show, like, depending on your perspective on the man, a Stan Lee cameo in a Marvel movie or the wizened old man-shadow of Murnau’s Nosferatu. For all of its (many) flaws and questionable moments, the show is intensely watchable and serves, in many ways, as a near-perfect time capsule of the mid-2000s era.
The show’s episodes mainly revolve around quite frivolous storylines. I distinctly remember etiquette school, dog adoption, Halloween séances, and birthday parties, all highlighting an easy-going, aspirational, and distinctly American way of life rooted in comfort and excess. The purpose of this is twofold: throughout the show, the content clashes with the form. It is wholesome (not what one would expect of Hugh Hefner), and the sexuality is defanged and carefully managed. The “girlfriends” are presented as very much being “girl next door” types, something that is no doubt meant to feel somewhat shocking and salacious while taken hand in hand with the polygamy and pornography of it all. The second, more targeted reason is the contrast that the show often makes between Hefner’s chosen locales (most significantly, LA and Las Vegas) and other less glamorous, sexually-liberated places, both in the US and abroad.
The vague notion of “other places” becomes clear in season 1, episode 6 of the show, “Operation Playmate." The episode opens with Holly, the girlfriend who played a role most similar to Hefner’s wife, overseeing a slip-and-slide being set up for the mansion’s annual Fourth of July party, an image that leans heavily into nostalgic Americana. What could be more American than that? The party, complete with numerous stars-and-stripes bikinis, bookends the episode, which is centrally concerned with the girlfriends and other Playboy playmates, or centerfold models, taking photos in “military bunny costumes” and baking cookies, which Bridget takes as a care package to her brother and his friends, who are stationed on a military base in North Carolina. In this way, the episode is reminiscent of Korean War-era USO shows. The military bunny costumes, the care package with signed photos, the televising of it all: this is Marilyn Monroe singing to the soldiers for a 21st-century audience.
It’s a pretty typical episode as far as the show is concerned. There is mischief and kerfuffle about costuming, the eccentric rules inherent to life at Playboy, and an extravagant party, with a few moments meant to feel emotional. However, the episode is, undoubtedly, trying to play a role in shaping the audience’s understanding of the ongoing Iraq War. Bridget and her brother are instrumental in this. We learn that her brother, Eddie, has “served two tours in Iraq, one in Afghanistan,” and is about to be deployed again. He is presented as a role model for the audience to look up to, as Bridget tells the camera, “I’m very proud of my brother. He had a whole career and a life going, and just dropped everything after 9/11 to join the army, and now he’s going back to Iraq. I’m very proud of him.”
The central endeavor of the show is to tell the audience that Holly, Bridget, and Kendra are normal girls-next-door who just so happen to live in a 43 million dollar mansion while all dating the same man. If Eddie is supposed to walk the line of relatable and aspirational, so too are the women of the show. If Bridget is representative of an idealized everyday woman, and her brother is narratively, in this episode, her male counterpart, the archetypal American woman is a Playboy bunny, and the archetypal American man is a soldier. There is a sinister implication to this: both “archetypes” have bodies to be drafted into a cause not entirely their own, albeit in very differently gendered contexts.
The vested interest of Playboy complicates things further. The care package that Bridget brings to Fort Bragg feels more like a modern influencer’s PR package in that it is meant to serve as advertising. This one scene from a trashy reality TV show serves as a microcosm of the interrelatedness of sex, gender, capital, and American militarism of the era.
The episode closes with the mansion’s annual fireworks show. It is paired with a voice-over, again from Bridget, who tells us, “the fireworks make me kind of teary-eyed because I think of my brother and all those people that I know who are out there today fighting for our country, and it’s really important to remember all that they’re doing for us right now.” Much like the scene of all the Playboy bunnies baking cookies in the mansion’s kitchen, we are left with the distinct impression that the women are holding down the fort at home, while the men fight abroad. At the Playboy Mansion, like across America, it is largely business as usual. War, invasion, and the damage they cause are something very, very far away from here.