The Ghost of the French New Wave in La La Land

Many of us think of La La Land as a contemporary classic of the movie musical genre. As someone who is obsessed with the movie, I am captivated by the vibrant hues of purple and yellow, as well as the catchy soundtrack that I can’t stop singing. To me, it felt like there was nothing that was or will ever be like La La Land.

So imagine my surprise when I was in my Film Music class, and our professor showed us the “Sans Toi” scene from Cléo from 5 to 7 – it looked strangely familiar. As she waits for biopsy results, Cléo Victoire, the main character, rehearses her song while filled with existential dread. The camera moves closer and closer to her, the background transforms into pitch darkness, and our focus turns to Cléo’s face as she sings with anguish towards the camera. In my mind, I heard Mia sing “Here's to the ones who dream / Foolish as they may seem.” I couldn’t shake the parallels that I was drawing with the audition scene in La La Land.

It turns out that scene with Emma Stone was actually a direct visual and thematic homage to Agnès Varda’s masterpiece. La La Land director Damien Chazelle intentionally used a similar staging to transform Mia’s raw, spoken story into a powerful artistic manifesto.

I was also very inspired when I discovered one of Chazelle’s , favorite films, The Umbrellas of Cherbourg. The film’s dialogue, conveyed through operatic singing, initially turned me off a bit. But as I watched the entire movie, I realized how essential the singing was to convey the emotion of the characters in the film. This feature, along with the film’s bittersweet, time-skipping narrative structure, is strongly reminiscent of La La Land.

Right from the start of La La Land, we open with arguably the grandest musical number of the film, Another Day of Sun. This song immediately establishes the main message of the story: achieving your biggest ambitions often requires painful personal sacrifices. Every other song after that is also a pivotal point in the plot. After watching The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, I was able to fully appreciate how crucial the musical aspect of the film was.

Just as the two main characters in The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, Geneviève and Guy, are separated by life circumstances and forced to marry another spouse despite their undying love for each other, Mia and Sebastian also part ways due to their diverging artistic careers. Both sets of characters run into each other years later and make acknowledgement of each other with a bittersweet aftertaste, leaving the audience with a brief “what could’ve been.” Chazelle makes the juxtaposition of fantasy and reality very obvious, with the Epilogue montage, which imagines the life Mia and Sebastian could have had together. The Umbrellas of Cherbourg makes the comparison a bit more subtle, where Geneviève leaves Guy to his wife and son in a magical winter scene. They play in the snow like a happy family, yet Geneviève and Guy’s love song plays in the background, encouraging the audience to imagine Geneviève there instead of his wife.

The films’ color palettes also mirror each other. Neither film shies away from using bold colors in the backdrops and in the characters’ clothing. In The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, the bright pinks, blues, yellows, and greens make almost every frame look like a painting. The colors reflect the heightened emotions of the characters and the dreamlike quality of their romance. La La Land similarly uses color to create a world that feels slightly removed from reality. Mia and Sebastian’s clothes often complement the colors of their surroundings, making them feel like they are part of the same carefully constructed world.

However, the way the two directors use color also reflects the different eras that their films come from. Demy’s use of color feels more theatrical and fantastical, which fits the romantic idealism of the 1960s. Chazelle draws from this same visual language but uses it in a way that feels more modern. The colors in La La Land are still vibrant and exaggerated, but they exist alongside a more realistic story about careers, ambition, failure, and compromise.

This is probably the biggest reason why I connected more with La La Land. As someone who is an ambitious career go-getter, I found Mia and Sebastian’s struggle between their relationship and their careers much more relatable. Their dreams require years of hard work, rejection, and sacrifice. The film acknowledges that sometimes achieving your dreams means having to make a choice between two things that you love, even when neither choice is necessarily wrong.

In this way, I think The Umbrellas of Cherbourg is more representative of the mindset of its time, while La La Land feels more relevant to the way people think today. Demy’s characters are shaped by romance, circumstance, and the social expectations of the 1960s. Chazelle takes these same themes of love, sacrifice, and missed opportunities and places them into a modern world where people are expected to pursue their individual ambitions.

Overall, I really enjoyed seeing how Chazelle was able to draw from older films while still creating something that feels completely his own. La La Land is clearly inspired by films like The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, from its use of color to its musical storytelling and bittersweet ending. Yet Chazelle transforms these elements into a modern masterpiece that speaks to the experiences of people today. For me, that is what makes La La Land so special. It can feel like an old Hollywood musical and a story about modern ambition at the same time, taking inspiration from the past while making it relevant to a new generation.

Previous
Previous

Beautiful Brutality: How Raging Bull Turns Masculinity Against Itself

Next
Next

Sequel Mania: What Makes a Sequel Worthy in an Oversaturated Market?