“Does the new Spider-Man movie have all that multiverse nonsense?" my dad asked me earlier this year. Surprisingly, despite the recent multiverse craze, the answer was no. But that simple question made me think about the mass cultural fatigue that develops from sequels that require too much “homework” (the need to consume copious amounts of prior media to understand the plot and premise of a sequel) and feel soulless.
Then I watched Toy Story 5. Going in, I knew the film had exceeded $1 billion at the box office and that people praised it as a “worthy sequel.” But what is a worthy sequel? How can a fifth movie in a kids’ franchise be so strong? Is it not just a cash grab? I needed to see for myself. The online audience was right. Toy Story was the perfect franchise to showcase the harms of social media. The writers’ decision to make the iPad, Lilipad, an antagonist instead of a villain added incredible nuance. Lilipad has the best interests of Bonnie at heart, she just doesn’t understand that tech can’t solve Bonnie’s entire social life. The story of finding Bonnie an IRL friend fits right in with the zeitgeist.
This movie wouldn’t have thrived just with a great plot and familiar characters. The hook for sequels is the novelty of spending time with longtime “friends,” but we stay tuned in for many other reasons. With Toy Story, I realize the timing of the release was hugely beneficial. It’s been 31 years since Toy Story debuted, which makes Woody’s bald head reference all the more fitting. Further, the previous installment came out in 2019. Thankfully, the producers were patient enough to allow audiences time to grow and develop nostalgia for the franchise.
Thus, we can say that for sequels to be worthy they must (a) have a strong plot with something resonant to say (this element requires producers to avoid filming TikTok-adjacent trendy scenes that only exist to serve short attention spans), (b) have careful timing between installments, (c) build on an initially interesting concept with fleshed-out characters, and (d) avoid demanding the consumption of so much prior content (“homework”) that audiences get discouraged. We can understand these four factors outside of the Toy Story context by exploring how 2026 sequels have achieved or fallen short of them.
Spider-Man: Brand New Day successfully explored how young men often feel lonely and lost in our current world. Doctor Strange's spell that made “everyone to forget Peter Parker” in the previous movie feels less like a gimmick and more like a vehicle to explore loneliness in a superhero context. The 4.5-year gap between installments was long enough that audiences craved more but not so long that audiences lost their love for the franchise. Further, Spider-Man is a strong series because of teenage Peter Parker’s instant relatability. Finally, by removing the multiverse, Brand New Day limited the amount of Marvel Cinematic Universe homework.
The Devil Wears Prada 2 fulfilled the four criteria for a strong sequel. The movie explores how the behavior Miranda once got away with (like demanding 24/7 availability from her staff) is no longer tolerated in 2026 as it was in 2006, providing a perfect commentary on modern corporate America. Miranda and Andy are always compelling characters because of their tyrannical-boss, struggling-employee relationship. Finally, this universe only had one prior film, so it was easy to catch up, and the 20-year gap allowed the story to naturally form. These four factors surely explain the financial success. With Spider-Man: Brand New Day, one could say the movie would have been successful even if it didn't have the four criteria because Spiderman is so popular. The Devil Wears Prada didn’t have years of content to increase anticipation among its fans and therefore was more reliant on nailing the four criteria.
On the other hand, Star Wars: Mandalorian and Grogu struggled to fulfill the four criteria, which limited the potential for box office returns. According to critics from Substack and Flick Direct, the film felt more like multiple TV episodes stitched together than an “event” film with real stakes. The flood of shows on Disney+ has, to some extent, tarnished the brand. Just like the MCU, the Star Wars universe lacks approachability due to the homework required to actually understand what the hell is going on—a first-time viewer should not have to watch upwards of ten movies as background. Arguably, the only thing the movie had going for it was that it was an extension of a strong franchise that has incredible worldbuilding. Even then, newer projects within Star Wars have shifted away from the most iconic characters like Luke, Leia and Yoda.
Other films have fallen into the same trap. 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple (released too soon after the first film) and Scary Movie 6 (oversaturation for a weak horror concept where the only tension comes from the same masked man every installment) come to mind. Looking ahead, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping looks like it will fulfill all four criteria. The authoritarian government mirrors elements of our own society. It has been three years since the previous installment—an adequate gap. Plus, the movie franchise is contained enough that anyone can join, and the prequels have expanded the stories of characters that viewers actually care about.
The upcoming Pixar film Incredibles 3 has provoked controversy. While the franchise is strong, the decision of the director (Brad Bird) to have the characters not age could result in a missed opportunity for resonance. Despite this, the movie will likely perform well as signaled by the success of Pixar’s Incredibles 2. This raises a question: can a movie be worthy because of economics even if it sacrifices story to achieve those ends? So far, we have only explored movies that have been successful versus unsuccessful and how the four criteria contributed to the relative success. But if a movie fits all four criteria and is unsuccessful economically, does that immediately make it not “perfect?”
Moreover, Brad Bird drives us to think about the difficult topic of character continuity. Can a sequel be a good movie but not a good sequel if the characters change too much and take actions that don’t make sense? Moviegoers today call this “character assassination.”
Ultimately, there is no universal formula to create the “perfect” sequel, although the four criteria (resonance, timing, expansion of a strong concept, and minimization of homework) can serve as a guide. I could go on and on about how Spider-Man live action movies should be ~four years apart, and Toy Story movies should be seven years apart. The past can't entirely predict the future, though. Quirks in culture prevent the perfect distance between movies from being an exact science. “Classics” can’t truly be predicted. Furthermore, what might resonate with some won’t resonate with others. Does that mean we shouldn’t make that movie?
Also, if we are trying to construct a “good” instead of “perfect” sequel, does it really need all four of these factors? If the plot is strong enough, maybe there doesn't need to be a large amount of time between sequels. If the franchise is compelling enough, maybe people are willing to do the homework. For movie sequels to be “perfect,” arguably they need all four. But for sequels to be good, they don’t. Lastly, are some factors more important than others? Is this hierarchy based on the franchise, or can it be universally applied? Arguably, plot is the most important because it creates resonance through cast, location and tension. With enough time, though, people can crave any type of movie, no matter the plot.
Essentially, there exists a fundamental challenge when making movie sequels. Studios need to provide familiarity while also giving audiences something new. The best studios can do is apply the lessons to the best of their abilities but ultimately be okay with the subjective idea of “perfection” in this business. While we would prefer for every movie to be clearly worthy, this will never happen. If anything, the flood of mediocre sequels helps the worthy ones truly shine.