The opening credits of Martin Scorsese’s Raging Bull are simple yet elegant: white text on a pitch-black background, accompanied by the Intermezzo from the opera Cavalleria Rusticana. As the music swells, a boxer shadowboxes alone in an empty ring. Without any dialogue, Scorsese establishes the film’s central theme: the self-destruction at the heart of toxic masculinity. Raging Bull tells the story of Jake LaMotta, a 1950s boxer, depicting both his domestic life and his boxing career. Scorsese uses the ring as a metaphor for the abrasiveness of LaMotta’s life, contrasting beautiful cinematography with the ugliness of its central character.
To understand the film, one must first understand Jake LaMotta. Born in the Bronx, LaMotta had a troubled childhood. Outside the ring, he was married to Vikki, whom he met at an early age, and their marriage was fraught with violence. The other key figure in his life was his brother, Joey, who managed his career. The tragedy of LaMotta’s life centers on these two people, whose relationships he destroyed through his own self-destructive actions. The film depicts this through two scenes. The marriage comes to a head in a fight late in the film, sparked by LaMotta’s paranoia and insecurity over Vikki’s possible affairs, including one with his own brother. That same paranoia leads LaMotta to beat Joey in front of his family, severing their relationship. Years later, LaMotta’s request for a kiss from his brother is met with a cold shoulder, showing the damage is beyond repair.. Throughout the film, Jake treats love as something to be won through dominance. When Vikki remarks that a young opponent, Tony Janiro, is good-looking, LaMotta proceeds to disfigure him in the ring, as though beating a rival could secure her loyalty. He cannot read tenderness or trust as anything but weakness, so he answers them with force, and the same instinct that makes him a champion makes him impossible to live with.
Raging Bull is, in my opinion, Scorsese’s magnum opus because it contrasts beautiful cinematography and editing with the abhorrentness of its central character. Michael Chapman delivers some of his best work here. The black-and-white photography gives the film a documentary feel that adds authenticity, while the fights are shot with a theatrical quality, as though each were a moment in a larger play. Thelma Schoonmaker’s energetic, pulsating editing sets the film apart from other boxing films and heightens every scene. All of this contrasts with Jake’s repulsive behavior inside and outside the ring. That contrast is deliberate. The beauty draws us into admiring the tough-guy image, just as LaMotta admires it himself. When the story tears that image down, we are left wondering why we were drawn to it.
The final fight against Sugar Ray Robinson shows this best. Until then, aside from the fight he purposely lost, we have only seen LaMotta destroy his opponents. This bout comes after he has alienated both Vikki and Joey, and rather than putting up any opposition, he takes every punch on the chin, ending with a flurry from Robinson. The edit cuts between Robinson’s punches and LaMotta’s bloodied face, making the punishment feel like penance for what he did to Vikki and Joey. The scene is graphic and disturbing, yet almost impossible to look away from. It ends with LaMotta telling Robinson, “You never got me down,” showing how distorted his perception of himself, and of the masculine image he must uphold, has become.
In Scorsese’s filmography, Raging Bull sits at a turning point between focused character studies like Mean Streets and Taxi Driver and the sweeping stories of Goodfellas and Casino. Comparing it with Taxi Driver is especially meaningful because of their central figures. Travis Bickle, an isolated, desperate New York cab driver, and LaMotta are, in a sense ,mirror images. Bickle directs his frustration with himself outward at society, whereas LaMotta turns his anger inward, using boxing to release it. Both films treat masculinity as a trap that only makes things worse. At the end of Taxi Driver, though many hail Travis as a hero, he is empty; none of it improved him as a person. In Raging Bull, Jake is forced to ruminate on how his actions destroyed the people he once loved.
Raging Bull is filmmaking at its finest, using cinematography and editing to contrast its larger narrative. It is my favorite film for its exploration of masculinity and its tragic story. I have never seen a film with as much emotion and nuance, and Robert De Niro’s performance, full of anguish and devastation, is one of my favorites. Everyone should watch it. It does not please the viewer; it forces the viewer to reconcile with themselves.