Wes Anderson’s Moonrise Kingdom follows two twelve-year-olds, Sam Shakusky and Suzy Bishop, who fall in love and plan to run away after becoming pen pals. Both feel ostracized and neglected, though they come from very different backgrounds: Sam is an orphan who has bounced between foster homes and scout camp, regarded as an unlikeable troublemaker by his peers. Suzy is the “problem child” of her family, prone to violent outbursts and regularly rebelling against her emotionally distant parents. The pair find comfort in one another and devise a plan to run away and create Moonrise Kingdom, a world that brings them the stability missing from the homes and institutions that have failed to protect and understand them. Throughout the film, Anderson reverses the expected adult-child hierarchy; the adults tasked with finding the runaway children and restoring order are confused, lonely, and disconnected from the roles they perform, while Sam and Suzy, however erratic and impulsive, seem to be the only pair who know where they are going and how to get there. In doing so, Moonrise Kingdom asks how much of adulthood is itself a performance, and whether “growing up” actually provides the emotional clarity and stability children are taught to expect.
The performance begins with the world Anderson builds around his characters. The Khaki Scout camps on New Penzance Island are almost comically organized, stressing order in this society. The Scouts run on strict schedules, they are evaluated on their uniforms, formations, and ability to complete assigned tasks, and Scout Master Ward surveys basically everything. Police Captain Sharp and the Bishop parents represent authority, procedure, and order. They communicate and interact almost robotically with each other, Sam, Suzy, and their environments. Just as order is ingrained in its inhabitants, it is built into the visual aesthetics of New Penzance Island.. But, behind all this symmetry in the adult-managed world lies chaos. The Bishops’ marriage collapses due to affairs and miscommunication, and the adults in their own authoritative domains struggle to effectively communicate with one another, even when two children’s safety is compromised. Everyone seems to know exactly what their job is, but not themselves.
Although Sam and Suzy fail at the roles they are given on New Penzance, they succeed at the ones they create for themselves. The adults’ institutions identify Sam and Suzy as outliers and as problems within their communities. Sam, who has struggled through the loss of his parents and constant moves between foster homes, doesn’t fit in with the Scouts. He is bullied and stereotyped as a bad Scout. Likewise, Suzy realizes her parents have categorized her as a troubled child and that she doesn’t fit within her own family. After being told that they don’t function “correctly” in their worlds, Sam and Suzy plan an intricate escape while slowly falling for each other. And, as they do, they suddenly function remarkably well. After traversing New Penzance Island and setting up camp at Moonrise Kingdom, Sam and Suzy build their own miniature domestic world. The two divide responsibilities, talk, dance, kiss, fight, and make up. They begin to perform adulthood more sincerely than the adults themselves. Their kingdom may be objectively make-believe, but it is the most emotionally honest “home” Anderson shows us in the entire film.
Dialogue plays a crucial part in distinguishing the ironically juvenile adults of the movie from the strikingly mature children. The adults often filter their feelings through roles, avoidance, and bickering. Laura and Walt Bishop repeatedly have verbose conversations that lack meaning throughout the film, speaking to each other as lawyers rather than partners. Similarly, as Laura and Captain Sharp “end” their affair, it feels like they are following a script. Laura says, “I have to do better for everybody, except you,” and Captain Sharp replies, “I think you will. You are doing the right thing.” Their monotonous voices and rigid diction make this breakup scene feel like a transactional exchange, as they retreat into the socially prescribed roles of wife and police captain, rather than confronting the complicated emotions between them. Conversely, Sam and Suzy are incredibly direct about their feelings. In their conversations, there is almost no separation between feeling, saying, and doing. When they talk about Sam’s foster family, Suzy naively claims she wishes she were an orphan because their lives are more “special.” Sam corrects her immediately, responding bluntly, “I love you, but you don’t know what you’re talking about.” In a movie otherwise filled with the procedural, monotonous droning of superficial adults, this exchange stands out as one of the only moments in the film where a character exhibits emotional clarity. Sam and Suzy never claim to understand everything nor do they claim that their escape is “right.” Their maturity comes from their unusual willingness to acknowledge exactly what they want, and the sincerity they have cultivated in one another slowly starts to bleed onto the adults around them.
Over the course of Moonrise Kingdom, Sam and Suzy influence the people around them. The Scouts, who initially enforce conformity by rejecting Sam and setting out to capture the pair, eventually feel remorse, and break the rules to help Sam and Suzy escape again after they are caught at Moonrise Kingdom. Scout Master Ward, once the embodiment of procedure, gets swept into the very disorder he was supposed to prevent, while Captain Sharp breaks away from his role as a policeman to protect Sam and take responsibility for him. The people who were meant to find the children and restore order increasingly violate that order themselves. The Scouts break formation, and, soon, the whole island seems to follow: Sam gets struck by lightning, Fort Lebanon is destroyed, and a record-breaking storm hits, tearing through New Penzance. Throughout the film, characters try to control uncertainty through schedules, legal procedures, and fulfilling their assigned roles. Then a storm that none of them can control arrives, and the physical world begins to look as chaotic as their social one has been all along.
By the end of the storm, the original order of New Penzance is destroyed, and a new one takes its place. Sam and Suzy don’t remain runaways forever, and neither their fantasy kingdom nor the world that rejected them in the first place can survive. Captain Sharp takes responsibility for Sam, the Scouts who once ostracized him accept him, and Sam and Suzy are able to remain connected without having to escape into a world of their own. In a way, the children force the adult world to make room for them. Moonrise Kingdom may have only existed temporarily on a secluded beach, but the sincerity Sam and Suzy created there survives in the relationships they return to. Anderson does not suggest that growing up means finally having all the answers. Maybe it just means learning when to stop pretending that you do.