Amid the excitement this summer surrounding the release of The Odyssey, there was one bit of critical rhetoric that stood out to me. While it seems like most people enjoyed the epic, there is a vocal subset who disliked the film and have taken aim at one particular aspect. Indeed, demonstrated both in social discourse and official promotional materials, the film is not The Odyssey, but Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey. Rarely in film history has a work been so fundamentally inseparable from its director.
Beyond just the discourse that surrounds this film in particular, however, there has been genuine critique aimed at the repetition of themes in Nolan's work. Practically all of his films dating back to Memento have had some sort of time shenanigans, both within the story and through the timeline in which scenes are presented. More recently, many people have also reasonably noted that Cillian Murphy’s Oppenheimer bears a striking resemblance to Matt Damon’s Odysseus. Those most familiar with the original text of The Odyssey seem to have found Nolan’s interpretation of Odysseus to be particularly odd. In the original Greek poem, Odysseus is generally portrayed as ruthless and unrepentant for his actions. Damon’s version, however, is defined largely by the regret he carries for his behavior, going so far as to say that a part of him does not even want to return home. Nolan reaches beyond the poem to portray Odysseus as an Oppenheimer-like figure, tortured by the responsibility he feels for how his Trojan Horse changed everything, creating a chain reaction that would destroy his world. The similarity is too clear to write off as coincidence, and yet the criticism falls entirely flat for me.
Undeniably, Nolan has a particular style and particular themes that recur throughout his works… but why is that a bad thing? Over time, as I heard this gripe repeated over and over (ironic considering the qualms the critics seem to have with repetition), I couldn’t help but think of how absurd it would sound if someone looked at the works of Vincent van Gogh and said they liked Sunflowers, but thought the style was too repetitive by the time they got to The Starry Night. It is almost a contradiction to suggest that an artist shouldn’t have a unique and recognizable style.
Of course, critics might respond that it is not a fair comparison. People will spend at most a handful of minutes admiring a particular work of art, far less time than Nolan’s three-hour epics demand. So, consider works of literature. Would it ever be considered a bad thing for an author’s style and the themes they care about to consistently shine through? I think the answer is no, and so I wonder what makes the way we interact with films different. Why is it that we tend to separate films from their creators much more than in other art forms?
Perhaps the answer comes down to how we view movies. Part of it is that films are often viewed as a form of entertainment to consume rather than art, but I think the difference runs deeper than that. This whole discussion reminds me of Studio Ghibli, which has an artistic and thematic style even more consistent and long-running than Nolan's, yet has never really faced this criticism. The best explanation I have for this discrepancy is that Ghibli’s themes tend to shine through worldbuilding and character, rather than filmmaking choices. While Nolan’s decisions to tell the story out of order and to change an established character like Odysseus are observable, Hayao Miyazaki’s hand is much more subtle.
Why, though, do we have this expectation that the touch of the artist ought not to be seen in film? Why shouldn’t Nolan, or any other director, use the camera as Van Gogh used his brush? Part of what makes art so wonderful and so important is that it is a lens through which viewers can see the world in a different light, from a different perspective. I think we sometimes have a tendency to want our films to be neutrally created, mere reflections of the script, the world, and the characters. Yet some of the greatest aspects of film arise from what the script can’t convey, from when the world comes to life and when actors leave their mark on their characters. The creative visionaries behind the camera ought to be able to do the same.