*Spoiler warning
With the release of Netflix’s new East of Eden miniseries on October 1st, John Steinbeck’s sweeping, generational epic and reimagining of the Book of Genesis is set to either gain a fresh breath of cinematic life or join a long list of cash-grab, classic-adaptation failures. It is infamously difficult to faithfully bring any beloved piece of literature to the screen while still adding something innovative or worthwhile to the story. With a novel as complex as East of Eden, taking the form of a miniseries rather than a film is already a good sign for adherence to the source material. With Elia Kazan’s 1955 film adaptation as direct proof, a two-hour running time is simply not long enough to dig-in to all the nuance of a novel with such a wide scope. In his adaptation, Kazan chooses to only focus on a single character, Cal, from the novel’s era-spanning ensemble, effectively omitting the first two-thirds of the entire book, as well as countless integral characters and plot points. This bold choice, however, offers an interesting new lens through which to view the story: while Kazan does not adapt the full breadth of East of Eden as the title of his film would suggest, he did add something to the story’s essence through his specific examination of Cal.
Zeroing in on a certain perspective is a simple yet effective way to bring new profundity to a primordial story. The risk in doing so, however, is that it could end up detracting from the story’s larger narrative. While Kazan’s film made no attempt at complete accuracy, his version does succeed in giving viewers a better understanding of what Cal specifically embodies in the story: inherited evil, neglect, and the choice to be good. By reorienting aspects of Steinbeck’s epic exclusively in relation to their effects on Cal’s character—and even including new, fully original plot points—the film forgoes its status as a traditional adaptation. These creative liberties, while arguably detrimental to the film’s alignment with the original 1952 novel, are exactly what deepen Cal's purpose in the adapted narrative. Because of them, we feel a greater sympathy for him, and his multitudes as a self-sabotaging protagonist are on greater display than ever—especially due to James Dean’s stunning breakout performance. Kazan took a bold swing that may have cost his feature greatly, but also solidified it as essential to the East of Eden canon.
For Netflix’s 2026 miniseries, marketing has revealed that creator and writer Zoe Kazan, Elia Kazan’s granddaughter, is adapting Eden through the lens of Cathy, Cal’s mother. In a novel primarily about good and evil, Cathy is a pure embodiment of the latter. The miniseries already looks to be a more faithful adaptation of Steinbeck’s original novel, both aesthetically and due to the inclusion of central characters like Lee and Charles. But by potentially shifting Cathy’s function in the story, the miniseries risks the possibility of straying further from the original novel. Cathy is a character fascinatingly steeped in contempt for the world around her, and analyzing her motives through an episodic form might prove to be very fruitful to the Eden zeitgeist. However, if Zoe Kazan chooses to pivot from the source material and transform her into a more empathetic character, the integrity that made the original novel’s character so captivating could be lost completely. Harkening back to the Book of Genesis, Eve’s position in the story is one of perpetual nuance: the first human succumbing to temptation is a foundational story not just to Christianity but humanity at large, and the implications behind this quintessential moment have been studied for millennia. Yet, if Eve’s actions were to be radically recontextualized following the original story’s publication, not only would the chronicle gain no new meaning, but the addition would actively undercut the initial significance of Eve’s characterization.
It could be interesting for viewers to observe Cathy and her behavior contextualized through other characters’ effects on her. As the 1955 film does with Cal, the series could help us understand how the motivations behind her actions directly reinforce the themes she represents: we could explore why she decides to shoot Adam, the specific details of her murdering her parents, or how she is able to abandon her twin sons, Cal and Aron, forever. Further exploration of these actions have the potential to enhance the character’s classic wickedness—making her and her deeds all the more terrifying—but the adaptation will disgrace its source only if it suggests Cathy’s decisions were beyond her own control.
In an interview with The Atlantic, Florence Pugh, who will be playing Cathy in the miniseries, stated that the cast and crew did not want to do “just the easy, cheap version of making [Cathy] a villain.” Pugh also said that the goal in making Cathy “the engine of the story" was to give her “a bit of tenderness,” and to “get underneath all of the decisions that she makes.” I don’t inherently have a problem with either of these ideas, but to suggest that a pure, villainous portrayal of an infamously evil character is simply “easy” or “cheap” is disheartening. In no way do I want the character of Cathy to lack dimensionality, for a complex villain—Cathy being one of the all-time greats—is an archetype that deserves just as much attention as any sympathetic protagonist. If the Netflix series is able to add appropriate nuance to Cathy’s story while maintaining her characterization as a villainous psychopath, it could potentially surpass Elia Kazan’s adaptation to become the definitive cinematic version of East of Eden. As with all derivative works in film and television, however, the miniseries could very easily squander Eden’s narrative integrity or, worse, directly contradict its iconic themes. If there is one thing to take away from Kazan’s original East of Eden, it is that bold swings are often worth the risk, as cinematic adaptations of literature can never—and perhaps should never—be completely identical to their source material.