He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not: The World’s Now Most Famous Victim Complex and The Role We All Played In It

Before we begin I’d like to preface where I stand with my letterbox review of Obsession. “Obsession is a film about a girl quite literally crushed under the weight of a man's audacity. While being held against her will, sent on a quest, by him, to find where he gets it, she ends up in the darkest pits of hell.” When asked to pick between man or bear, I will tell you that I choose the bear. Unless we’re talking about Obsession, then I’d prefer not to choose at all. Bear, the antagonist of the film Obsession, is a boy driven by his own selfish fixation on a girl who has yet to reciprocate his affection. When left unsatisfied by his unrequited feelings towards Nikki, he snaps a magic twig referred to as a “One Wish Willow” and thereby forces what is a shell of the girl he “loved” to finally “love” him back. However, in Bear's defense, he didn’t actually think it would work.

The hot-or-not obsessed girl trope has been played out and explained across many iterations of film and television, think Baby Reindeer, Crazy-Ex Girlfriend, Cassie from Euphoria, Kelly from The Office, or just that one female character in every Disney or Nickelodeon sitcom. The story is always the varying flavors of the same thing. She stalks him (but in a light hearted comedic way), shows up unannounced and uninvited to his door, commands all his attention, limits his female friendships, is mildly vindictive, etc. Whether or not he chooses to tolerate her actions is typically determined by how attractive she is. If he uses the metric of her beauty to accept his fate, then he is no longer considered a victim by the audience. Additionally, as we are equally as entranced by her striking appearance, we too (the audience) let her actions slide. In other words, the hotter you are, the crazier you’re permitted to be.

Inde Navarrette, the actress that portrayed Nikki Freeman, is stunning by any measure of the word, but there is no level of beauty worth aiding and abetting a murderer, not even touching her other plentiful indiscretions. Under any other circumstances, Bear would be considered a victim, but as we know the audience and the director and actors all do not.

A shallow husk of who she used to be, her looks are the only resemblance evil Nikki bears to her original self. Bear is fully aware that the two are different beings who merely share a face and body; they are visually identical twins. His obsession with her physical attributes and his own self interest are why he puts up with her, in addition to the fact that her actions are a fate he brought upon himself. He deserves every second of the fate that we are forced to endure. A film’s message is only as powerful as the consensus of the audience to agree. Barker’s message being, If you’re beautiful, no amount of kicking and screaming will free you from the fate that man has decided on your behalf, and as such the consequences for enforcing that truth are nobody's fault but his (Bear’s) own. Barker didn’t leave our understanding of the film up to chance. No, No, No. Our agreement with the story's message is ensured by the medium in which it is told and the weaponization of the medium itself.

Upon leaving the theater, what stuck with me most was the ringing in my ears from Navarrette’s sudden outbursts. Whether from the corner of a bedroom, the center of the floor, or the driver seat of the car, you were just as trapped Nikki was, stuck on the opposite side of a dimensional divide. You are empathetic for Nikki in a world where she does not exist. You are the only testimony, witness to her insanity, the only person who may have listened to Bear when he needed someone else to grant the second and the only person to corroborate Nicki's story at the end of the film. You are tortured just as she is, by the sound of her voice, the vocalization of her pain—except you chose it, you consented, and as you sit there, you are starkly aware that Nikki did not. You are helpless, and she is, too.

Silenced in a dark theater, the only light cast upon your face travels from the screen. The chair you sat in is worn out with the cushion pressed in and tattered from the friction of viewers past. It rests at an angle that’s just barely upright and curved to force your neck into a tilted position. The hunch in your back is reminiscent of the night before spent slaving away at a desk chair equally as uncomfortable as the one you’re sitting in now. Still are your lips, sewn shut by the promise to keep quiet. Your ears begin to ache at the mercy of a sound engineer who couldn’t be bothered to choose a decibel range not akin to a five-alarm fire. Fifteen of the dollars you woke up with in your bank account have now transformed into butter-drenched popcorn that tastes like all the salty tumbles you’ve taken in the ocean.

You are not to be seen or heard. You are a witness. Held hostage by the shrieking of her “NO, NO, NO, NO,” you are subjected to what you deep down know is always coming: the sound of Bear’s mistake. The audience is saved from the repeated plunging of his own body into Nicki over and over again as she lays there unable to move or garner any form of agency. Stripped of her autonomy like a lifeless corpse, she’s crushed under the weight of his audacity.

However, considering that we are spared from the most brutal and legitimate aspects of Bear’s wish as mere audience members and retain the option to leave at any time, perhaps the role we play is a closer approximation of Bear than of Nikki. As I said, we do nothing, we say nothing, we pay to watch the movie. Curry Barker created this film because he wanted to tell a story. Of course, every movie isn’t without its economic incentives, but unlike the endless supply of Marvel movies or Disney live action remakes, I far from believe that making money was his chief objective. This belief is especially backed in an interview he gave The Hollywood Reporter, in which he said he was offered 2 million dollars to re-write the script with Bear as the hero, an offer he honorably declined in order to maintain creative liberty and tell the more authentic and compelling version of the story. This means that without the expectation of viewers like us, the story would have never been told, and Nicki would have never been cursed to begin with. The audience and Bear are the only ones who know how to save her, and we do nothing. We are bystanders, because we are helpless by design. After all, we can’t reach through the screen and encourage Bear to end his life, or grant another wish to contradict his original sentiment. We have no choice but to be entertained.

If it were Barker's intention to make us a collection of villains and draw a true parallel between Bear and viewer, the film would have ended when we decided that we had finally had enough. As in we could no longer stand to watch Nikki be tortured, so the film would magically end, terminating her suffering. Since that’s not how movies work, however, we instead exist at Bear’s whim and are released from purgatory alongside Nikki when he has had enough.

Nikki is an overdramatized version and embodiment of the word obsession, but it is not hers the film's title is referring to. The consequences of a One Wish Willow are brought about by the request of the user, meaning there could’ve been none. Nikki was ultimately tormented because it is impossible to love someone more than anyone else in the world without losing yourself. If taken literally, as the willow does, it requires you to love them more than you love yourself. Perhaps the two could have been more compatible if Bear loved her as much as she loved him, but the only person Bear loves is himself, which only fueled her rage because Evil Nicki’s very existence contradicts his validity of any claims he had of affection. When you think about it, Bear did get what he always wanted. He got some version of Nikki to return his feelings, but he didn’t love her. His wish was driven by his own obsession, so it is what he received in return.

We are an integral part of the story, we play the jury. The same jury that so many women don’t get. When the film ends the final question is, will people believe her story?

Previous
Previous

Ketchup Spaghetti and Broken Promises: The Death of Hong Kong through Wong Kar-wai

Next
Next

Bob Mackie’s Legacy in his Costumes for Went with the Wind!