A few weeks ago, my girlfriend took me down the hill to RISD’s Fleet Library. As I trailed behind her, enamoured by the ornate ceiling, she led me to a small room hidden underneath the staircase in the center of the hall. Inside, there were a set of bean bags folding on top of each other, a wide screen TV, and a small black box that I recognized with profound nostalgia. It looked, to my memory, exactly like the one my family had stopped using years ago. I’m not really sure where it went: Perhaps it's still hidden in some closet somewhere, or maybe it just stopped working and was thrown away, never to be replaced. In any case, as I knelt down in the dim light to trace my fingers across the surface, I recognized a simple, yet magnificently satisfying tactile mechanism, and pressed. A light mechanical whirring sounded, and a small circular dish opened up.
While I admired the DVD player, my girlfriend had gone to explore the library’s film section. She returned holding a thin plastic case with the image of a girl atop a white wolf. Princess Mononoke, an old favourite of mine. I opened up the case to a crisp click and gently removed the disc. My delicate touch was a combination of knowing that this paper-thin disc contained a story that meant so much to me, and that I could easily snap or scratch it if I wasn’t careful. As we sat down to watch, I found myself drifting further into nostalgia, wishing ambiently that things were always like this—that streaming had never been invented and that all films were still watched this way. In hindsight, the irony of my absolutism is amusing.
I love Princess Mononoke because of its wholehearted embrace of complexity. The protagonist Ashitaka, a stranger to the lands of the story, finds himself in the middle of a fundamental conflict between nature and technology. First, he meets the people of Irontown, a mining community whose forge has been damaging the surrounding environment, corrupting the nearby forest’s spirits into violent demons. While speaking with Irontown’s leader, Lady Eboshi, Ashitaka learns that their iron corrupted the demon that attacked his village—the reason he is here. Yet, as Ashitaka looks at Irontown, he sees with eyes unclouded, and recognizes not only the corruption of their technology, but also its benefits.
Irontown is not a dominion of evil, but rather a place of freedom and accessibility: Women who had once been slaves are free in Irontown, and the townspeople craft weapons not to dominate others, but to empower the oppressed to defend themselves. Eboshi can be ruthless, but Ashitaka learns that she is motivated by deep compassion: She seeks to heal her citizens who suffer from leprosy using the mythical blood of the forest’s Deer God. Yet, when Princess Mononoke, the human daughter of forest spirits, attacks Irontown, Ashitaka steps in to protect her when she is cornered by the town’s guards. Caught between two factions that hate each other to the point of war, Ashitaka sees only the love that motivates both.
Even in the end, when the Deer God has been slain, Ashitaka remains steadfast. As Mononoke grieves, she accuses him of being on the side of humans and moves to stab him out of anger. He responds only by embracing her. Together they go on to return the stolen head of the Deer God to the forest, bringing forth a wave of greenery that overruns the carnage of the preceding battle. The Deer God remains dead, and the mechanical haven of Irontown has been destroyed, but in abandoning absolutism, both sides find peace. Princess Mononoke remains in the forest, Ashitaka in Irontown, and they promise to visit each other. The world can have both: nature and technology, the old and the new.
If you hadn’t already guessed, this story is not just about my love for Princess Mononoke. I have seen the film three times now: on streaming, in the theater, and on DVD. The first was during Covid: In lockdown, my family watched a movie every day, and it was only because Princess Mononoke was available online that I was able to see it (and fall in love with it). A few years later, I had the chance to see a re-run in theaters at Providence Place, and loved the immersion of the big-screen experience. And now this time, on DVD: I loved the feeling of holding the disc in my hand, enough to know that I would gladly spend $20 to own a physical version of something I love forever.
It seems like a constant battle in film these days that theaters are going out of business, that no one wants DVDs anymore, and that streaming is corrupting the beauty of film. These things may be true, but are also not absolute. The potential drawbacks or harms of each format should not wash out the joys and freedoms they offer in return. Just as the Deer God truly is gone, the world will never be as it was when DVDs were all we had, but that doesn’t stop us from still appreciating them, nor should it stop us from embracing new technologies that make film more accessible than ever. At least for me, Princess Mononoke is a reminder that I love film more than I fear change.