Prometheus and Ridley Scott’s Xenomorph Mythmaking

When Alien (1979) was first released in the cinema, audiences were fascinated by Ridley Scott’s Xenomorph, and the claustrophobic terror it created when people are stuck in the vents with this nine foot tall acid-spitting horror. It was one of the earliest moments of cinematic wonder. Because of this, it procured a faithful audience for the eusocial insectoid-reptilian, despite looking a bit like schlock by contemporary standards. However, in “Prometheus” (2012), these reptilians have lost their charm.

Prometheus is Ridley Scott’s pet project made to look like a space epic akin to Kubrick’s 2001 Space Odyssey but with less narrative deliberation. The movie is set in 2093, where archaeologists discover an ancient sumerian star map and arrive at moon LV-223. There, scientists discover a new prototype of xenomorph dissemination (colloquially called “Black Goo”) and the aliens who designed them 2000 years ago to wipe out the human race. A series of catastrophic events occur, where all members of the exploration team die and only the lead scientist, Elizabeth Shaw (Noomi Rapace), and an evil android ripped in half, David (Michael Fassenbader), survive. In the midst of conflicts, the Engineers attacked the humans and continued their course to unleash the Black Goo over Earth. It was unclear why these alien giants decided to not only create but also wipe out the human race, at least not until Scott’s own testimony where he reveals that the reason for an alien rage is because we murdered Jesus Christ, who was an emissary sent by the aliens to correct our path.

This Chirsitan narrative is quite unfamiliar to the Alien fanbase. The franchise has long been plagued by the nebulous pseudoscience surrounding the xenomorph. Every new contrivance of a xenomorph has been made more for box office shock value than for artistry. It has always benefited from the element of surprise, allowing it to stand underexplained and shrouded in a cheap, back-alley fortune teller obscurity. However, Prometheus deviates from this tried-and-true formula. This deviation is why the undertaking doesn’t work. Scott tries to align the genealogy of a monster with the themes of sacrifice, creation, and preservation of life, the result of which is a garbled amalgamation of some false alien totality; even worse, an alien cult where the xenomorph stands at its head. It is not to say that the xenomorphs are disgusting creatures that lack sophistication, but the expensive cinematography only makes the monsters seem contrived in retrospect. All that to say that Scott dresses up his voodoo monster with the Emperor's new clothes.

What Scott had intended to embark on, I think, was an imagination of an alternate human ontology vis-à-vis the creation of an alien myth. He asks: If Kubrick’s “2001: A Space Odyssey” was a retelling of Nietzsche’s Thus Spoke Zarathustra, then how can the eponymous titan’s story be told if humans were granted audience with the deity that gave them life? In “Prometheus”, we learn that the “Engineers”—an alien, humanoid civilization that had given the Sumerians and mesopotamian cultures technology—designed both the humans and the means of our destruction.

With Scott’s mythologizing ambitions in mind, it is hard to divorce the classic image of the chestburster from the myth of Prometheus, or even Jesus. The chestburster grows from a Facehugger-implanted embryo and matures into a full-sized Xenomorph within hours. It, as its name suggests, bursts through the chest of its inhabitants. Scott drives home the image of the bursting stomach where Dr. Elizabeth Shaw, pregnant with an alien baby, lies in an advanced, automatic, voice controlled operating table and extracts the abomination from her stomach. (She sutures herself, for those who are wondering.)

Scott’s alien life comes at a cost: like the titan Prometheus, one must have their stomachs violently opened to breathe life into a civilization, especially one not of your own race. The lack of dignity and grace in this scene, however, falls short of Scott's philosophical narrative. If self-sacrifice and the birth of a whole civilization (vis-a-vis a women’s womb) is supposed to be an honorable cause and an awe-inspiring moment, Scott doesn't fail to subvert our expectations. In “Prometheus,” it means a scene of claustrophobic, obstetric horror with unappetizing gore to match. If anything, we learn that Caesarians are no joke and that Scott is really a feminist, as he empowers Shaw to take out an alien baby from her stomach.

The universe created by Scott’s' new alien ontology functions as far as it brings a form of a divine to the foreground, but the divinity that Scott contrives is completely unsound and unscientific. This is Scott’s version of the Greek myth, by which he argues for a set of pseudo-philosophical ethics. It constantly legitimizes itself with its profuse references to antiquity and is matched by a gore-heavy aesthetic where self sacrifice isn’t a moral question, but really a Freudian toss-up between a scene of alien abortion or coerced fellatio with tentacles.

At the end, Scott provides us glimpses of his space-alien epic with reference to precivilization myths, but his treatment of his alien babies merely as aesthetic objects falls short of his teleology, resulting in senseless carnage and gore that cannot understand the scope of Scott’s imagination of an alien other. There was perhaps a moment of a Biblical confrontation between humans and aliens that may have warranted musings on the morality of self-sacrifice and human creation. However, this moment is butchered when we are reminded that either it is impossible to imagine divine will, or that Scott’s version of gods are just violent aliens and that he himself is the arbiter of the Alien cinematic universe. His alien/xenomorph totality is regrettably incomplete—they are incapable of anything beyond total destruction, which, ultimately and regrettably, is Scott’s argument. The product of this venture into alien origins is thus a facsimile of a myth backed by pompous images with no philosophical deliberation. There is no hero, god, nor archetype in “Prometheus” except from the bloodthirsty xenomorphs that operate under the fickle ethics of their master—Ridley Scott.

So the question that ends up being asked is one that belongs in the midnight History channel: What if we meet our bald, white, and alien gods whose pets will brutally murder us and force us to give them xenomorph babies just because we killed Space Jesus? I supposed you really should never meet your hero.

Previous
Previous

A Story About Physical Media (And Princess Mononoke)

Next
Next

Reimagining Black Queerness in Film