You see how this looks, right?

I will undress you. You will undress me.

You see how this looks, right?

In a dark room, dimly lit by the fluorescent hum of vanity lights, a man in a tan suit sits hunched over, clutching a series of printed text messages in his hand. A bead of sweat rolls down his face, tracing a path along his protruding forehead vein. He methodically repeats the words.

I will undress you. You will undress me.

Again.

You see how this looks right? You see how this looks right?

There’s a knock at the door. The subject is early. Five minutes early. Downstairs, a camera crew is setting up, placing recording devices behind potted plants and hidden cabinets as a group of people gather around four monitors. Adrenaline rushing, costume changes, makeup, moving set pieces, a plate of cookies placed on the kitchen counter. Then, silence. They stare intently at the screens, waiting for any sign of movement.

A car pulls into the driveway, and a short, middle-aged man steps out. He is the subject.

Hey! Come on in.

A voice rings out inside the house. She is a decoy, a thirty-year-old woman masquerading as a teenage boy. The subject steps inside, cautiously surveying the surroundings, looking for any signs of suspicion. He smells the cookies. Seemingly there is nothing wrong; this is a tight operation after all – this is PRIMETIME TV.

Then the man in a tan suit emerges.

Big night plan, huh?

The subject gulps loudly.

I will undress you. You will undress me.

The suited man slowly walks down the stairs.

You see how this looks right?

Chris Hansen directs this question at the predator he’s confronting, but PRIMETIME gradually turns back on him, and ultimately on audiences. When we take a closer look at Robert Pattinson’s portrayal of Chris Hansen in Lance Oppenheim's PRIMETIME, we’re left with more questions than answers. The film depicts American television presenter Chris Hansen during the production of his 2004-2007 NBC show, To Catch a Predator, where adults seeking sexual encounters with minors were lured into televised sting operations. The director guides audiences through an intensely subjective examination of Hansen’s internal psychology, set against the backdrop of post-9/11 America, ultimately revealing the devices through which the pursuit of justice can become entangled with ambition, commercial entertainment, and politics.

A documentarian by trade, Oppenheim’s previous films include Some Kind of Heaven (2020), a documentary that explores The Villages retirement community in Florida and Spermworld (2024), which uncovers the informal online market for sperm donation. Unlike his past works, PRIMETIME completely drops all pretence of objectivity, opting for a highly stylized color-grade, twisted unnerving soundtrack, and luridly expressionistic magic-realist imagery, making it obvious that it isn’t just aiming to replicate another generic docudrama. There is a deliberate contrast between the hyper-realistic goal of “To Catch a Predator,” which presented itself as a form of journalism, utilizing hidden cameras, compared to PRIMETIME’s surrealism and dreamlike construction.

Oppenheim’s depiction of Hansen portrays the television personality in a less-than-glamorous light. He is disloyal to his wife, absent in his children's lives, and obsessed with chasing fame. Hansen’s obsession with fame and self-importance is comedically highlighted as when, calling a vending machine company after his chocolate gets stuck, he introduces himself as “Chris Hansen from Dateline NBC”. Before appearing live, Hansen paces in anticipation with glazed-over-eyes, relishing the moment he gets to step into the spotlight and deliver his televised justice for captivated audiences at home. We watch and laugh as the predators have their lives ruined, tackled to the ground by police and humiliated. “This is what they deserve” we tell ourselves; or, in fact, what Chris Hansen deems they deserve.

The “real” Chris Hansen certainly does not approve of Oppenheim’s portrayal of him, stating that “everything else is fictionalized” and that he was “unfairly portrayed”. In the same Variety interview, Hansen suggested that, “I think for some people, if there’s an intervention when they’re young, if there’s a commitment to not reoffend, to dig deep in therapy, there is redemption.” The film’s Hansen seems to stray from the message he proposes in real life, and indeed, Pattinson’s portrayal is heavily stylised and plays off dramatic effects like monkey noises or sporadic movements.

So how valuable is a docudrama that doesn’t accurately represent its subject matter? Are we able to trust Oppenheim if he so blatantly guides our point-of-view?

I would argue that the true value of docudrama lies not solely in the accuracy of its representation, but rather in its ability to reveal fundamental truths about its social context. Using To Catch a Predator as a narrative framework, Oppenheim interrogates the ethics of justice within America’s twenty-first-century digital landscape, asking, who has the authority to judge and punish the actions of others? Can anything have a truly altruistic intention, especially in an industry that constantly demands more engaging and sensationalist stories? PRIMETIME doesn’t provide us with a singular answer.

In the face of what Hansen describes as an “ancient evil”, anything is justified. He himself states that what he does (televising these predators to the public) is “a little worse than” beating them to death. The 2020s have been littered with vigilante predator catchers aiming to mimic Hansen’s hit show, popping up on Twitch and YouTube. In these cases, the influencers subject caught predators to all sorts of outrageous punishment and humiliation, far beyond what Hansen did on his show, forcing audiences to question: Are these actions genuinely undertaken in the service of justice, or does the language of justice merely legitimize a pursuit of media attention and fame? It is undeniable that it is the predators’ humiliation that generates ratings and engagement, in which case, the two seem inseparable.

Oppenheim highlights this, as Pattinson screams, “WE’RE GOING TO BE BIGGER THAN LOST”. The crux of the film is driven by this pursuit of fame, attempting to catch “a whale” (a predator with an important government position), framing this “catch” as one of heightened significance and greater moral effectiveness, whilst ironically letting “less interesting” predators go unpunished as they wouldn’t be as entertaining for audiences.

In the film, Hansen attempts to justify his position as judge, jury, and executioner by telling a fantastical story about his time in India filming a Dateline NBC series titled “Slaves to Fashion” (though the film adapts the premise of the show from child labor towards monster-hunting folklore). The lurid imagery, darkened color grade, and ominous supernatural environment further blurs the line between reality and fantasy, forcing audiences to question the legitimacy of Hansen’s “justice”.

Oppenheim draws several parallels between this morally ambiguous depiction of justice and the heightened tension of post-9/11 America, embedding his film deep within the backdrop of early 2000s America, perpetuated by constant depictions of Osama Bin Laden and Saddam Hussein. As Hansen justifies his actions on moral basis, whilst paradoxically benefitting and driven by his pursuit of fame, America’s “War on Terror” under Bush’s presidency similarly upheld a self-important guise of justice as a justification for an expansion of executive powers. The expansion of surveillance powers under the USA PATRIOT Act, growth of defense spending, and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq were directly fuelled by narratives of moral vindication. In the same way Hansen’s battle for ratings and “moral significance” with major news networks were built upon structures of mass media and entertainment, as was the “War on Terror” influenced by popular opinion following 9/11. In both instances, the media landscape is framed as a battle for attention and ratings rather than based upon any form of just foundation.

In a world of personal ambitions, to what extent are "saviours" driven by some actual higher purpose?

Whether it be Hansen, major news networks, or the American government, the film doesn’t give us a clear answer. However, its notion of ambivalence exposes something about us, as an audience, and what our fascination with Hansen’s show reveals about our own moral standing. Do we support the forms of “justice” enacted? Do we gain a twisted sense of pleasure from the punishment of the morally wicked? Or are we simply fuelling systems of “just” retribution determined by those who had no right to enact them in the first place?

At the end of the film, Hansen stands shellshocked, drowned in rain and backlit by the garish police lights surrounding the scene of his latest sting operation. Inside the house, the dead body of a predator lies cold on the floor. The body of a Texas court prosecutor who wanted to meet a thirteen year old boy. The gun is still smoking in his hand. Blue and red lights infer justice. How can we justify his hand in the death of this man?

We're cleansing the world of an ancient evil

Repeat the text messages.

I will undress you. You will undress me.

This man is evil.

I will undress you. You will undress me.

You see how this looks, right?

Previous
Previous

How Every Avenger Voted in the 2024 Election

Next
Next

Verity and Resident Evil: Two Sorts of Slop