Verity and Resident Evil: Two Sorts of Slop

In order for a film to be self-aware, it must create the perfect tone. A movie might have abysmal writing, subpar acting, and a convoluted plot, but if it sets a tone that encourages viewers to embrace these shortcomings, it might be more effective than if it were a technical masterpiece. Verity (2026) precisely understands itself as a slop movie. Michael Showalter’s adaptation of the Colleen Hoover novel aims only to entertain, and he undoubtedly achieves this. Zach Cregger’s Resident Evil (2026), another recent horror film, is antithetical to Verity in almost every sense of self-awareness. Cregger’s adaptation of the beloved video game series thinks that by flaunting its own mindlessness, it will somehow be more than slop.

Although I am relatively unversed in both films’ source material, their respective relationships to what they are adapting is clear. Cregger did not want to make a movie that transplanted the video games’ iconic characters and plot points into a cinematic recreation. Instead, he wanted to convey the feeling of playing a Resident Evil game through series staples such as a slow escalation in weapons and danger levels, a linear progression in unlocked territories, and a feeling of unending terror that pervades the entire runtime. I think this is a brilliant approach to a cinematic video game adaptation. To my knowledge, however, no Resident Evil game feels equally balanced between comedy and horror. The continuous jokes not only dissent from the video games’ tone, but they annihilate any tension or fear the audience might feel, while also being shockingly unfunny. The protagonist’s constant cursing, quips and lack of genuine fear render him unbearable and the movie itself impossible to take seriously. Even in rare moments of solemnity, we hardly recognize Bryan because his only previous character trait was humor. In an emotional scene, viewers realize we don't know who he is if he’s not making a joke or screaming “FUCK!” And even in an abruptly climactic moment, when Bryan loses himself completely, we can’t emotionally resonate because we already lost him the second he stopped being comedic relief. This same sequence is also supposed to be the big plot twist, yet it takes place seconds before the end of the movie where it cannot possibly have any ramifications. Without having played any of the games, I know there is usually a final villain with a motive, or at least an enemy that has more psychological substance than the first braindead zombie we encountered. But for the film to do the same, it would mean being so vulnerable as to create a single character that it takes seriously. Here, the final villain is the first zombie Bryan ran into, only bigger, and she is easily defeated without a real battle. By cramming in jokes and deliberately choosing not to take big narrative risks, Cregger attempts to demonstrate his knowledge that he is merely making a trashy horror flick. But in doing so, he forbids the tone from becoming dramatic enough for audience immersion and never makes a remotely entertaining choice. When the director feels they are too good for the film they are making, so does the viewer.

Conversely, no part of Verity thinks it is too good for what it is. Showalter’s greatest proof of self awareness is perhaps that he does not insist upon this cognizance whatsoever. He entrenches the small scale story in more drama than Resident Evil ever manages to achieve. Following a struggling writer who agrees to ghostwrite for a famous author before discovering her secrets, the film never once takes a step back from the drama of its characters. Viewers are not looking to be intellectually enlightened with any slop movies. But since Verity sincerely invests in the emotions of the story, the audience can’t help but feel them too. Additionally, where Resident Evil is too afraid to have a big reveal that affects the story, Verity’s constant plot twists, while at times hard to make sense of, are what makes the film so fun. Although it is almost a whole half hour longer, Verity is never as stagnant as Resident Evil is throughout its entire runtime. It may be the mindlessness of the film that makes it so easy to digest, but that levity is never pointed out in a way that pollutes the tone. While its writing is never masterful, the screenplay’s omission of any opportunity for jokes proves that corny drama is by far more enjoyable than banal comedy. Not only does the film take its characters seriously, but the characters themselves care so much about their own story. The main character in Verity is more threatened by a mysterious sound in the night than the protagonist in Resident Evil is by hundreds of zombies attacking him, and viewers are automatically engrossed in this fear. Neither film’s characters are likeable by any standard, but you cannot help but root for Verity’s, simply because of how much they are rooting for themselves. Where Cregger strides for a meta relatability through a suspension of disbelief in dire situations, Showalter demands for the audience to resonate with his characters by making their plights apocalyptic in scale. Verity masters the self-aware slop movie because it knows exactly what it is without telling the viewer it knows. Whereas Resident Evil takes pride in its mindlessness in an attempt to prove it could be something “better” if it wanted to be. While Cregger works against his film's slop status, Showalter embraces it and is unafraid to make a genuinely trashy piece of cinema.

Next
Next

Persona and the Filmic “Zahir”