The Maximal Image

Most films are active in the way they communicate ideas and tell stories. When I sit down to write about a film, I analyze intentional narrative, plot, symbolic, or cinematography choices. How does all of that mesh to teach the viewer something?

Zorns Lemma shows but it does not tell. Watching it felt like entering some manipulative meditative state that made me emote and experience in ways that forced me to unknowingly alter my own intuitions.

The first thing the film gives you is comfort. A woman’s voice reads a children’s educational primer pairing each of the 24 Latin letters with a moral verse. It is relaxing. Structured and well-ordered.

Then Hollis Frampton subverts your experience of that structure. For 45 minutes, the film loops through one-second images of words beginning with letters of the alphabet. Frampton slowly replaces each letter with an image. First images with X are replaced with a fire. Then Z is replaced by light shimmering on water. The structure remains, but the information it preserves does not. The mind reaches to read these images the way it reads the words they replaced. But as the cycle continues, it increasingly fails to do so. Somewhat uncomfortably, your grasp on the letters loosens.

And without the film telling you anything, the state it puts the viewer in makes them realize that the act of reading is unnatural. To read a word is to intuit the image of it so quickly that the image disappears entirely. In a way, language is a system for not seeing.

Now is a great time to talk about the film’s title. Zorns Lemma is a set-theoretic principle stating that if every ordered subset in a partially ordered set has an upper bound, then it contains at least one maximal element. More casually, it formalizes the intuitive notion that whenever you are climbing a set of stairs, there must always be a last step.

Perception is not purely cognitive. It is indexed by who, where, and when we are. We do not see and then interpret those visuals. We see as people in a place at a time. Frampton breaks that habit. The alphabetic structure is a pitfall. Attempting to force images into that structure is frustrating, and that frustration is the point.

What happens when our perceptive habits break is the real subject of the film. As the “alphabet” of images cycles, something shifts in our attention. The images begin to arrive differently. Not as letters, but as what they are. The fire is fire, the light shimmering is purely light shimmering. In that instant, we have reached the top of the staircase. Language hits its limit of meaning. What remains are images self-sufficiently standing alone.

The final ten minutes of the film are intuited through this purely experiential lens. A man and a woman walk slowly into a snow-covered landscape while a voice reads aloud a text about light and vision. Watching any other film, we would be quick to think about purity, death, or silence. But in that moment, we have been conditioned to only see.

It is easy to think that Zorn’s Lemma is obscure for the sake of self-indulgence. It is long, repetitive, and difficult. But in actuality, the film is surgical in its precision. It identifies something that language-based art cannot do and builds a structure to do exactly that. The surgery is clean. The viewer does not learn, they unlearn. A feat that is rarer, harder, and perhaps more useful.

Previous
Previous

Clerks: The Monumental Scale of Daily Life

Next
Next

How Guardians of the Galaxy Defies Marvelization