How Guardians of the Galaxy Defies Marvelization

The cultural dominance of Marvel superheroes over the past two decades has been undeniable, just as its collapse in relevance has been. In the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s “Third Phase”, lasting from 2016 to 2019, six of eleven films released grossed over a billion dollars at the box office. Of the thirteen films released since 2019, though, only two have reached that mark, and six have failed to reach over 500 million, which had not happened since 2011. Many have attributed the fall to “Superhero fatigue”, others have suggested a diminishing quality in writing and production, and some have explained it through “Marvelization”: a trend characterized by compulsive jokes and quips that undercut drama, an obsession with interconnected universes, and excessive reliance on CGI and action set-pieces. While originally used in criticism towards other studios that have sought to imitate Marvel, the focus has increasingly turned inward over recent years.

And yet, despite all the criticism that revolves around this so-called Marvelization, at the inflection point of its progression in the mid-2010s is a film that appears on the surface to embody many of these issues, and yet it has escaped criticism to remain persistently beloved. As will become clear, Marvelization is not so much the use of comedy, interconnectedness, and action, but the misunderstanding of it.

When Guardians of the Galaxy first released, people praised its use of humor and its lighthearted tone, and the CGI-reliant, sci-fi galactic setting served as an avenue for a huge expansion of Marvel’s cinematic universe. On the surface, it seems to embody the Marvelization which people have become so sick of and, at a glance, it would be relatively easy to argue that the 2014 release of Guardians is where everything started to go downhill. Alternatively, some have argued that the film’s brilliance is to blame for Marvel’s later struggles, with later films trying and failing to emulate the film’s unique success. This theory is furthered by director James Gunn’s placement at the head of DC’s new Universe, indicative of even other studios hoping to recapture the magic of Guardians. Going back now to rewatch the film illuminates where Marvelization goes wrong, how it captures the surface appearance of what makes Guardians so great, yet misses out on the values that underlie the film.

It is true that the film leans heavily into comedy, and it does sometimes use humor to undercut dramatic moments. Yet Guardians is separated from recent Marvel films by the consistency of its tone. For all the comedic moments that the film has, they are never treated as divided from or in conflict with the drama. What makes the “Guardians” special is a blend of heroism and absurdity. They are space pirates, talking animals and plants, blue and green aliens, and self-described jackasses. And yet the film refuses to separate their absurdity and their flaws from the sincerity of their heroism. At the climax of the final battle, they succeed because of a dance battle, in all its tension-carving, comedic glory, and then use the power of friendship to wield their enemy’s power. Neither part of this final sequence diminishes the other. They rely on each other. It is the natural way this story should conclude: with a comedic blend of absurdity and sincerity that proves that the misfit nature of the Guardians does not stop them from becoming heroes.

As for Marvel’s infamous franchise-building. Guardians of the Galaxy, being the first Marvel movie to be set almost entirely outside of Earth, is arguably the biggest step ever taken towards a hugely expanded MCU, but you wouldn’t know it if you just watched the Guardians movies. While they exist in the same universe, they are still within their own story, which is a complete narrative on its own and just as enjoyable without any broader context. The critical mistake of Marvelization is believing that being a part of a larger franchise is what made individual films enjoyable, demonstrated by the recent trend of putting crucial plot points for the interconnected story in TV Shows and niche movies. The truth is the opposite. What makes a franchise work is the bringing together of already established characters and stories.

Looking back, it’s easy to try and pick out where everything went wrong, or to smile at the good old days and declare that it’ll never be like it once was. Yet that’s not what I remember from going to see Guardians of the Galaxy for the first time, the first Marvel movie I ever watched in the theatre. I remember how much I laughed at the jokes and how much I loved the characters. I also remember how much Groot’s sacrifice stuck with me, the raw emotionality of a talking tree saying “We Are Groot”. I can’t say for certain what the future of Marvel cinema holds, but I know the problems it faces are in the execution, not the fundamentals. There was a time I had no idea who the Guardians of the Galaxy were, and I fell in love with a story that believed its characters could be absurd, stupid, beautiful and sincere all at once, that built its comedy through sequences and characters, and expanded on a broader universe without ever relying on it. For all I’ve said in this article, when I look back at Guardians of the Galaxy, I don’t think about Marvelization at all. The trend does seem real at least to an extent, and it might be true that a misunderstanding of Guardians’ success is part of what propagated Marvelization, but why should that matter? Why should a great film that stands on its own have to be defined in the context of its peers’ failures? To me, at least, it’s not the beginning of the end, nor the best we’ll ever get. It’s just good characters and a great story.

Previous
Previous

The Maximal Image

Next
Next

I Am in the Middle of the World