It's a quiet summer night in Vienna. There is a chill in the air, and you watch a young man and woman talking passionately while wandering from street to street. You stare at their happy, carefree smiles. You hear them reflect on human connection, God, and magic. You smile at their genuine laughs and affectionate banter that fill up the otherwise quiet city streets. Their world appears to be only the city, the two of them, and this singular night. It may only be a moment in their lives, but perhaps even a mere moment can be special enough to last forever.
Before Sunrise (1995), directed by Richard Linklater, captures the story of Jesse and Celine’s night in Vienna. The two of them meet on a train, form a connection, and quickly decide to spend the night together before Celine leaves for Paris and Jesse goes back to the United States. As far-fetched as the plot may seem, Ethan Hawke (Jesse) and Julie Delpy (Celine) put on performances that can only be described as genuine. The movie is, simply, dialogue between the two, completely immersing the audience in the complexity of their characters and interpersonal connection. By the end of the movie, you feel as if you know both of them inside and out, and maybe yourself a little bit more, too.
As they stroll through the city, their conversation goes from the street performers to the meaning of life. Celine begins passionately, “Loving someone and being loved means so much to me. I always make fun of it and stuff, but isn’t everything we do in life a way to be loved?” They sit down on a bench in the middle of a dim, quiet street, Jesse deep in thought. Eventually, he replies, “I don’t know, sometimes I dream about being a good father and good husband, and sometimes it seems really close. But then other times, it seems silly. Like it would ruin my whole life… I think I’d rather die knowing that I was really good at something. That I have excelled in one way.” Celine looks at him softly and says, “I believe if there's any kind of God, it wouldn't be in any of us, not you or me, but just in this little space in between. If there's any kind of magic in this world, it must be in the attempt of understanding someone, sharing something. I know it's almost impossible to succeed, but who cares, really.” The camera then zooms out to display the two of them sitting in silence, both smirking at their own attempt at greater understanding. Celine’s romanticized and emotional ideas on life complements Jesse’s purpose-driven ambition, revealing contradicting perspectives that urge us to reason with our own lives.
Set and released Nine years later, a real rarity in Hollywood, the two meet again in the sequel Before Sunset (2004)–allowing us to feel as if we are, in real time, following the relationship of Jesse and Celine. The sequel follows the same premise: only 12 hours together, pure dialogue, while traversing the streets of a city (this time, Paris). The movie begins by revealing that Jesse wrote a book about their night in Vienna. From there, the characters grapple with their past, the only constant between them, and the present, revealing a deeper complexity through their evolution.
Sitting in a car, they speak about the meaning of their present relationships. Celine says, “For me, I think it's better that I don’t romanticize things so much anymore. I was suffering so much all of the time. I still have lots of dreams, but they are not in regard to my love life. It doesn’t make me sad; it's just the way it is.” Jesse says in return, “Is that why you're in a relationship with someone who is never around?” The distress in Celine’s voice grows as they discuss her loss of romantic hope. Jesse sits, comforting her with a smile. “You can’t live your life trying to avoid pain,” Jesse advises, while offering anecdotes from his failed marriage, and then stating, “The only happiness I get is when I'm out with my son.” They begin to dwell on their night in Vienna and how it was the last time they both felt a true connection with someone.
This dialogue illustrates the evolution of these two characters: Jesse has now found meaning through his role as a father, entirely separate from his career success, while Celine has lost her sense of romanticism. These arcs contradict their stances on the human experience in the first movie, forcing us to reckon with the uncertainty and obscurity of life. Perhaps life cannot simply be viewed as either emotion or ambition driven. Instead, there must be balance and flexibility. But, then we are forced to ask ourselves whether their memories of Vienna are truly transcendent or if they are simply idealized, serving to mend the emotional gap in the characters’ present lives. What if they didn’t have to go their separate ways? We see how living life constantly through the past only infringes upon their ability to grow and continue living wholeheartedly.
After watching these movies back to back, I found myself pondering these questions and feeling rather emotional and empowered by the concepts it evoked. Through this experience, I began to gain a greater appreciation for the film's premise; it has no big plot lines or fight scenes, but, instead, it is simply an encounter between the viewer and the characters, sitting together amidst thoughtful discussion for 90 minutes at a time. I realized we are so used to the dramatics in Hollywood in this day and age, we forget about the power of complex character analysis. I believe we need more movies like Before Sunrise and Before Sunset that depict a multidimensional interpretation of the human condition and interpersonal connections, which, in turn, encourages us to reflect upon ourselves, our experiences, and the people in them.