Michelangelo and Andrei Rublev are perhaps the best examples of genre-defining artists, and the two are respectively emblematic of a High Renaissance and Russian iconic tradition. Both artists have received an apotheosis in the artistic sphere and have been elevated to a nearly-divine status.
In Giorgio Vasari’s 1550 Vite, the Renaissance art historian proclaims Michelangelo’s entry into the world in a manner that almost recalls Christ’s Incarnation and Nativity. Vasari writes that “He [the Ruler of Heaven] decided, in order to rid us of so many errors, to send to earth a spirit who, working alone, was able to demonstrate in every art and every profession the meaning of perfection in the art of design.” The notion of God “send[ing]” a “spirit” to earth recalls God the Father sending forth the Holy Spirit and bringing about the incarnation of Christ. Likewise, the fact that Michelangelo was sent by God to “rid us of so many errors” directly seems to parallel the way Christ is thought to die for the sins of mankind within Christian thought (1 John 2:2). Even the fact that Vasari describes Michelangleo’s work as not only perfect but the “meaning of perfection” in a Neoplatonic sense makes it seem as if Michelangelo defined what perfection means for the artist. And, in some ways, he did. Almost every single sculptor after Michelangelo will continue to define himself in reference to the man, usually in kinship with him as in the case of Bernini and Rodin, but occasionally in opposition to him, as in Brancusi. Regardless, it goes without saying that Michelangelo was the template of the artist in the Western European context, and that is true regardless of the medium, given Michelangelo’s triumph not only in sculpture but also in painting, architecture, interior design, and even poetry.
Similarly, Andrei Rublev has also received an apotheosis. He is known as Saint Andrei Rublev in the Orthodox Church, meaning Orthodox Christians quite literally pray to him as a vehicle of their prayers to God. Rublev also came to define a style of icon so thoroughly that he became a new reference for icon-making. Considering that Russian icons held strongly to established designs attributed to St. Luke and St. Veronica for hundreds of years, the influence of Rublev’s style in the iconic world cannot be overstated. Even the fact that Rublev’s name has gone down in history is important. Icon painters were expected to be vehicles of God’s will; individuality was not crucial for icon painters. For this reason, there are only a few names that survive in the icon painting tradition, and the best known of them is Andrei Rublev. Needless to say, these two titans of art history need no further introduction.
There are two often paired-together films that explore the lives of these two artists: Carol Reed’s 1961 The Agony and the Ecstasy and Tarkovsky’s 1966 Andrei Rublev. Within this pairing, film critics evince a sense of either disdain for Reed’s piece or strong sense of the superiority of Tarkovsky. Ben Davis from Artnet calls The Agony and the Ecstasy “wonderfully hokey” and criticizes Heston’s acting as “anguished mugging.” In a similar vein, Jonathan Jones from the Guardian complains that “art is simplified out of existence” in the 1961 Hollywood film. However, what both of these critics fail to realize is that The Agony and the Ecstasy does not seek to be a film like Andrei Rublev. Instead, these two films are representative of something more than just biopics. They represent competing visions of artistry and embody what it means to be an artist in different contexts. In this article, I’ll examine the differences in the presentation of these two artists in the two films, and what the two films reveal about how the audience can impact art and what the role of the artist is in society.
In The Agony and the Ecstasy, Michelangelo’s audience is clear, and he is tasked with completing ceiling frescoes on the Sistine Chapel for the papal court and Pope Julius II, but despite his demanding clerical audience, the artist manages to deliver a deeply idiosyncratic religious vision. One of the scenes that shows some of the input of the audience occurs around the middle of the film, when Pope Julius II and two cardinals inquire into Michelangelo’s work. The scene begins with a medium shot of Michelangelo tirelessly painting while standing upon scaffolding, and while the camera is focused on Michelangelo, the voice of a chastising cardinal emerges, and in a booming voice, the cardinal shouts “Obscenity! In the sight of God. In the house of his glory. Obscenity! Shameful! Shameful and obscene! This artist takes his inspiration from the Greeks who glorify the naked body” (1:21:06-1:21:16). After the first cardinal’s comments, the second cardinal claims that the “fault lies in having strayed too far from the Greeks…Barbarism!” (1:21:24-1:21:33). The dichotomy is clear. The first cardinal is portrayed as puritanical and prudish, while the second is pretentious and pompous. When Julius II asks Michelangelo what he has to say for himself in response, Michelangelo first refuses to respond until Julius II threatens to heed the criticism and remove the frescoes. After the threat of the destruction of his artwork, Michelangelo responds with a biblical justification for the nudity. When the priest responds that Michelangelo profanes the Word of God, the artist engages in a theological standoff with the prudish priest, proclaiming that “It was left to the priests to invent shame” (1:22:10), and in his booming voice, Charlton Heston as Michelangelo proclaims that “I will paint man as God made him” (1:22:16). After responding to the puritanical cardinal, the philhellenic cardinal suggests that Michelangelo paint “in the manner of the Greeks” (1:22:22). Michelangelo reacts to the comment by claiming that it is possible to surpass the Greek style and that his style is different from the Greeks. When the cardinal says that the artist should be above such distinctions between Christians and pagans, Heston delivers perhaps one of the best lines in the film, when he declares, “I’ll tell you what stands between us and the Greeks. 2,000 years of human suffering stands between us. Christ on his cross stands between us. And this difference is what I will express in my paintings. Just as I'll paint the truth in spite of all the bigots and hypocrites in Rome! Why do you bring fools to judge my work!” Heston delivers this line as Michelangelo much like he delivers his lines as Moses in the 1956 film The Ten Commandments. This showdown between the cardinals reflects an area where Heston’s authoritative tone becomes quite appropriate and even necessary for what the scene asks for. In both, Heston is authoritative and delivers his lines as if his words are the divine command of God. And the viewer leaves this scene feeling just that way. The viewer feels fired up at Michelangelo's words and grows bitter about those who do not understand his work, like the philistine and philhellenic cardinals. The two cardinals represent what the art historian Lord Kenneth Clark calls the “donkeys of the papal secretariat" when compared to the understanding and contemplative Julius II, who refuses to make a comment on the matter. The audience of Michelangelo’s frescoes is crucial to take into account because he is making the work for the cardinals. The Sistine Chapel is the location where the College of Cardinals elects the new Roman Pontiff, and the art serves as a reflection of the religious function of the room. But Michelangelo doesn’t make it seem that way. Rather, he delivers an independent view of art, one that ignores the views of his audience and proceeds according to his own artistic vision. That being said, the scene also demonstrates that Michelangelo is still bound by his patron: Pope Julius II. When Julius II asks Michelangelo to justify his art, Michelangelo must acquiesce and defend his artistic vision. In this sense, despite his great artistic license, Michelangelo as an artist is not entirely free to enact his vision as he pleases; he is still bound by the supervision of his patron, Julius II.
This scene in The Agony and the Ecstasy can be compared to one in Andrei Rublev, when Rublev feels deeply internally conflicted about painting a scene of the Last Judgment for the Assumption Cathedral in the city of Vladimir in Russia. The fact that Rublev has the privilege of hesitation demonstrates that his audience doesn’t put strict external pressure on him to immediately bring about the completion of his work. Unlike Michelangelo, who is shown painting at the beginning of the scene, Rublev is depicted in a remote field speaking to Daniil Chernyi, Rublev’s friend and the artist who is tasked with completing the frescoes with him. Rublev is petrified by the task of painting the Last Judgement for the Cathedral and does not want to do it. Indeed, he hasn’t even started. In the previous scene, a cleric inquires why Rublev has not even begun the work and asserts that a messenger will be sent to complain to the Grand Duke about the lack of progress. This frustration with the speed of art is common to the Agony and the Ecstasy as well, where Julius II repeatedly inquires when Michelangelo's frescoes will be completed. The difference between the two cases is that Michelangelo’s problem is that he cannot finish the frescoes; Rublev’s problem is that he cannot even bring himself to start. The obvious difference in patrons is that Rublev’s patron is geographically distant and lacks direct oversight over Rublev’s work. On the other hand, Michelangelo completed his work in the Vatican under constant supervision by Julius II.
However, on a deeper level, Michelangelo and Rublev see their audience as different. Michelangelo’s audience is secondary to his artistic vision. He only defends himself to his audience upon threat of the eradication of his art. For Rublev, the audience of his art means everything to him. Rublev is so concerned with scaring his Christian viewers with scenes of eternal suffering and damnation that he cannot bring himself to paint the Last Judgement. Rublev is not principally concerned with the formal qualities of painting; he is concerned with the effect his art will have on people. This can be seen in his conversation with Chernyi when Chernyi says, “For shame Andrei. A messenger was sent to complain to the Prince. Just say yes or no. We fixed it in Moscow, discussed every detail…Now, what is not clear?...The Day of Judgement. Go and do it.” For Chernyi, the task of painting the frescoes is straightforward. His tone when discussing the scene of the “Day of Judgement” makes it seem like it was no more visually complicated than any other commission and meant about to him as any other work. Likewise, Chernyi believes Rublev’s concern stems from the content of the work, given that he discusses the “detail” and how “clear” the subject of the Day of Judgement is to paint. In a sense, Chernyi is right. The Last Judgement is a subject depicted throughout art history, including by Michelangelo. However, the Last Judgement means something different to Rublev than it does to Chernyi. Rublev says to Chernyi, “I can’t paint this. I hate it. Can you understand it?” A fiery Chernyi fires back that he didn’t invent the subject of the Last Judgement. While Chernyi sees himself as a passive artistic instrument for visually transmitting the dogma of the Church, Rublev defies established art subjects, and by doing so, rebels against traditional religious topics. What’s fascinating is that Chernyi and Rublev have the same work in mind but envision different audiences. Chernyi paints for the Church, while Rublev paints for the Russian people. The reason he doesn’t want to paint the Last Judgement is because he says “I don’t want to frighten people away.” Rublev is concerned with how his art will be felt within the hearts of the viewing public. Michelangelo is an interesting parallel to Rublev because his audience is the Church like with Chernyi, but the contrast is that Michelangelo could not care less what the cardinals feel about his work, while Chernyi clearly cares about the desires of his audience. The Michelangelo of the Agony and the Ecstasy clearly does not respect the opinion of the cardinals, as he calls them both fools. In this sense, this paired examination of the audience of Michelangelo and Rubev’s work also reveals a great deal about the artist himself as either confident and assertive like Michelangelo or hesitant and self-doubting like Rublev.
Finally, it is worth looking into what the two films reveal about differing roles of the artist. In many ways, the roles of Michelangelo and Rublev are similar. The two both conceive of their art as a spiritual calling of sorts. In The Agony and the Ecstasy, Michelangelo receives inspiration for his art after looking at the clouds and seeing the scenes of Genesis within the clouds. In this sense, the spiritual awakening to make art is clearly within Michelangelo. Likewise, Rublev is motivated by a spiritual calling of his own, albeit only at the end of the film. In the ending, a teenage Russian boy named Boriska is tasked with making bells for the Grand Prince. During the process, the boy becomes wracked with increasing hesitation about the project. Finally, he asks for aid from God, and the bells are then pulled onto a tower where they are rung. In response to the ringing, the camera pans out and reveals a joyous crowd. However, Boriska collapses and cries because he made the bells, despite not being able to receive guidance from his late father. A comforting Rublev then tells him that Boriska will continue to cast bells, as Rublev will make icons. Boriska’s bells awaken a spiritual calling in Rublev. Boriska seems to serve as this epiphany because it seems like it reminds Rublev of his role as an icon painter. Unlike Michelangelo, whose primary role as an artist stems from action and continued painting throughout the duration of the film, the icon painter’s role is much more contemplative. Icon painters were expected to fast, pray, and receive a stroke of divine inspiration to make their icons according to established iconographic traditions. Likewise, Boriska prays and engages in a process of penance and suffering before realizing his artistic vision. Rublev sees this as the ideal for the artist, inspiring him to paint again.
For The Agony and the Ecstasy, the last lines of the film capture the role of the artist best. When Michelangelo sees how Pope Julius II has been emotionally moved by his work, he tells the pontiff that “It's only painted plaster.” The Pope responds, “No, my son - it is more than that... much more. What has it taught you, Michelangelo?” Michelangelo states, “That I am... not alone.” And the Pope concludes with the last line, “And it has taught me that the world is not alone. When I stand before the throne, I shall throw your ceiling into the balance against my sins. Perhaps it will shorten my time in purgatory.” Michelangelo’s answer to who taught him is not Ghirlandaio or any other artist; it is a philosophical answer. He answers humbly, which serves as a departure from the earlier Michelangelo in the film. This Michelangelo sees himself as “not alone,” implying that his art is inspired by a greater force than himself. But perhaps most notable of all is what Pope Julius II makes of Michelangelo’s art. The Pope states that “the world is not alone,” meaning that countless eyes will look to Michelangelo’s frescoes as inspiration and stand in solidarity with him. This is the crux of both films, and the two end with the notion that the role of the artist is to inspire the audience. For Rublev, the inspiration comes in the form of uplifting them through joy, and for Michelangelo, it emerges through an independent artistic vision. But regardless, the mission for the artist remains similar, despite the countless departures in how the two enact that central artistic mission.