Does Netflix Think We’re Dumb? The Rise of Anti-Intellectualism in the Age of Streaming

An average Friday night at the Richter household usually entails movie-watching in the living room punctuated with one of us either rushing to the kitchen to grab a snack from the fridge, needing to use the bathroom, scrolling on our phones, or my dad getting bored of the movie he randomly chose and leaving halfway through (sorry, Dad!). If I’d want an uninterrupted experience, I would truly have to watch it in the peace and dark solitude of my room. But needing that level of isolation just to pay attention says something larger about our shrinking attention spans—not just in my own household.

Late one night, I stumbled upon a clip with Matt Damon and Ben Affleck on The Joe Rogan Experience podcast (I know… bear with me) promoting their new Netflix film, The Rip, that perfectly summarizes the impact of our declining attention:

“The experience of watching [a movie] at home…I think [garners] a very different level of attention that you’re able to give to it, and that has a big effect and is also starting to have an effect on how you make movies. Like for instance, Netflix….they’re like, ‘It wouldn’t be terrible if you reiterate the plot three to four times in the dialogue because people are on their phones while they’re watching.’ And then it’s really going to start to infringe on how we’re telling the story.”

Streaming has certainly limited our scope of attention, giving us the option to pause and rewind whenever our attention veers in a way we don’t experience in a theatre, but I would go even further to argue that social media is the ultimate knockout blow to our attention spans. With the constant hits of dopamine from follower engagement and different video stimuli that keep us glued to the small devices in our hands, it’s no wonder large corporations like Netflix feel the need to have scripts repeatedly regurgitating the obvious: no one’s listening.

Although Netflix has adamantly denied this alleged strategy in the press, I think a prime example of this oversimplified and diluted dialogue was the season finale of Stranger Things. Receiving a brutal audience score of 52-57% on Rotten Tomatoes, thousands upon thousands of bad reviews online, and scathing personal anecdotes from my own friends, Stranger Things left dedicated fans forming crazed conspiracy theories, hoping that there was in fact a ninth episode that would fix the lousy, anticlimactic ending.

In the long-winded paragraphs of comment sections, I was intrigued to see that many viewers felt that the Duffer Brothers stated the obvious in their dialogue, as if they were writing a mandated plot summary to ensure audience members were following along. Characters would re-explain basic concepts, such as the hive mind, using various props or allegories to defeat Vecna in nearly every scene. This superfluous fluff unfortunately cheats the attentive viewers out of their fulfilling and worthwhile ending. Suffice to say, I’m glad I didn’t waste my time watching it myself. I’ll just stick with the ending of season four and imagine in my mind that the series stops there.

This pattern of deteriorating thematic depth in major streaming services like Netflix points to a broader cultural decline, one that films like Mike Judge’s satirical dystopian 2006 film Idiocracy, despite its problematic and outdated humor, cleverly portrays. The rather eye-opening film follows Joe Bauers, an “unremarkable” man in terms of his accolades who is selected for a top-secret military hibernation experiment, only to be accidentally forgotten and awakened 500 years in the future. What he discovers is a society in which anti-intellectualism has completely taken over every aspect of human life; humanity has finally regressed to the point where Joe is now considered the smartest person alive.

In this world, critical thinking has been replaced by mindless consumption and entertainment devolved into pure spectacle. Television shows like Ow! My Balls!, consisting entirely of the lead actor getting hit in the groin, dominate the airwaves and the hearts of its fans. Sure, I may have even chuckled, myself, at the idea of Ow! My Balls!, but the movie is not so far from the reality we live in now. I mean… look at something like Hot Frosty. No shade to Hallmark or Netflix Christmas movies—I’ll still binge them while decorating my house over winter break! But that’s precisely the point. These films are engineered to be effortlessly digestible. People have grown comfortable consuming palatable content that demands little to nothing from us intellectually. And over time, that comfort conditions the audiences to actually prefer content that asks for nothing, reinforcing a culture of passive consumption. Another television show, The Violence Channel, which is one of the most popular networks in the year 2505, solely dedicated to showing the exaggerated brutality of individuals getting hurt and public executions, addresses the rise of sensationalism in the media. Overall, Idiocracy’s exaggerated depiction shows the cautionary tale of how the pursuit of attention and necessity for instant gratification can ultimately erode the beauty of purposeful entertainment to little more than an empty spectacle.

Significantly cheapening the complexity and nuance of both characters and plot in film is simply an insult both to us, the viewers, and the art of media itself. Why strip the beauty from intricate stories that challenge us to think and reflect? If it’s beginning with film and television, what’s to say it will only stop there? This doesn’t mean we all need to solely watch avant-garde, 3-hour, underground films, but rather that we can resist this growth of anti-intellectualism by choosing to engage more intentionally with the media we consume. Because the same distractions I joked about in my own house—the constant snacking, scrolling, and distracted watching—are exactly what make meaningful engagement with the media so rare. Maybe now and then we should enjoy an excursion to the movie theatre watching something outside of our comfort zone…or better yet, simply put our phones down.

Previous
Previous

Reimagining Black Queerness in Film

Next
Next

The Shimmer: Fantastic Mr.Fox